She Said/She Said: Fancy a Bit of Pasty?

Well, Jennifer and I finally managed to sync our schedules enough for a quick lunch again! So we decided to check out The Pasty Shack, which seemed a bit odd but promising. First, we should point out that the word is pronounced "pass-tea," rather than rhyming with hasty. Apparently this business has been in Sacramento in various locations for 60 years! At 47th and J for only 16 years. That's a pretty impressive run. The history of these meat turnovers is that they originated in Cornwall, England, as a hand-held lunch meal for tin miners. Apparently they sometimes even have had a savory filling in one end and a sweet one in the other. So here's our She Said/She Said:
Ann's Take
I generally like anything wrapped in pastry, and I've had the Fox & Goose's version of the Cornish pasty, which is delicious. We lucked out by arriving on Mexican Pasty Day (Thursdays only), so had to try that one, along with a Cornish (meat and potatoes) and Vegetarian (mushrooms, potatoes, green beans, creamy sauce). They range in price from $4.95 to $5.70, although you save 25 cents each if you take and bake at home. Other choices include Bavarian (beef, cabbage, peppers), Chicken (like Veg but with meat), Tamale (Tue. only), and Chile Verde (Fri. only).
The place is pretty small, with only 4 or so tables, and maybe another one outside. The pasties are pulled from a hotbox if you want to eat them right away. They're each set in a paperboard "boat" and you get a plastic fork alongside. The pastry is a short dough (probably shortening) and was pretty tender and nicely browned. It got a bit soggy on the bottom of each turnover, but we weren't trying to pick them up. The plastic forks were not quite strong enough, but we managed. I liked the Mexican version the best, with juicy ground meat, spices, and cheese, but that's really not the standard. The Cornish, which is the standard, was a bit disappointing because the filling was sort of dry. There were nice chunks of beef though. The Vegetarian had a nicely creamy sauce, although I would have liked some more color in the veggies--maybe some red bell peppers or carrots?? Probably would've zinged up the flavor too. One of these is plenty for one person, so we had some left since 2 1/2-year-old Parker didn't seem too interested in these.
Jennifer's Take
Unlike Ann, I have never had a pasty before. And quite honestly I didn't really know what I was going to be eating as I was driving over to meet Ann for lunch, I just kinda pretended that I knew what a pasty was. The pasty shack is definitely lacking in the aesthetics, but the word shack does help lower ones expectations. As Ann mentioned there are four selections on the menu and because it was Thursday they threw in a "special". A pasty as it turns out is similar in appearance to a lean pocket (my sister’s freezer not mine) but I can only imagine that the calorie intake is not lean by any means. Out of the three selections my favorite was actually the vegetarian. The Cornish was too dry, the Mexican although decent in flavor had a hamburger helper'esq look. The vegetarian had the creaminess, the vegetables were overcooked and lacked in real color but if you closed your eyes the flavors were really quite nice. Now, I realize that historically pasty shacks do have their place in Sacramento Valley history--a short trip up to Grass Valley and you see like six of them. But I don't know if I love them, perhaps if they were offering up some sweet fillings like baked apples or sour cherries I would be a fan but then would they be a pasty? Probably not...more like those apple pocket pies that they sold in junior high. Umm, those were good.
The Pasty Shack
4746 J Street (next to Club 2-me)
454-9630 (you can call for take-out; free delivery w/in 10 miles)
11 a.m. to 8 p.m.

Comments
I was sad to read a disappointing review of the Pasty Shack. The crust alone is gold. True, perhaps the cornish can be a bit dry, but when I bring them home I make a Knorr's gravy and all is swell! Maybe that's what the Pasty Shack should do...offer gravy on the side.
Posted by: Laurel | April 29, 2007 10:01 AM
Gravy would be brilliant! I didn't dislike it, I just didn't love it. Agreed the crust is quite nice though.
Posted by: Jennifer | April 29, 2007 1:00 PM